Posted by
Doctor Poddy on Sunday, February 01, 2009 5:29:43 PM
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/headline/world/6241151.html
VATICAN CITY — Pope
Benedict XVI said Sunday that euthanasia is a “false solution” to
suffering, adding his voice to a bitter debate in Italy over the fate
of a comatose woman whose father wants to remove her feeding tube.
During his Sunday
blessing, Benedict said that love can help confront pain and that “no
tear, from those who suffer and those who are with them, is lost before
God.”
Benedict didn’t
mention Eluana Englaro by name, but it was clear he was referring to
her case, which has made headlines in Italy for months.
Englaro has been in a vegetative state since 1992 after a car accident. She was 20 at the time.
Her father has
fought a decade-long court battle to disconnect her feeding tube; he
says his daughter visited a friend in a coma shortly before her
accident and expressed the will to refuse treatment in the same
situation.
In July, Italy’s
highest court ruled that Englaro’s feeding tube could be removed,
upholding a lower court ruling. But Italy’s health minister, Maurizio
Sacconi, issued a decree in December telling hospitals across the
country that they must guarantee care for people in vegetative states.
Italy does not
allow euthanasia using methods such as fatal doses of drugs. Patients
have a right to refuse treatment, but no law allows them to have a
living will in case they become unconscious....
this is essentially the same as Terri Schiavo...
The problem is that the patients are usually described as "comatose" when they are actually severely brain damaged...if they are "vegetative" they can't swallow, and die of aspiration pneumonia (Average life span six months) which is why the church didn't object to not placing tube or removing them in the past...
what has changed is that the pro death people are removing tubes as a form of euthanasia, even though, like Schiavo, they are responsive (Schiavo was responsive on and off...her "vegetative" diagnosis was made by a doc who visited for one hour)...
an older British medical journal study showed that 45% of those diagnosed as 'PVS" were actually responsive to the environment...and more recent studies bear that out..
Ironically PET scans and MRI's are now finding many of these people do respond to the environment, and often their seizure or pain medicines make them only appear "Vegetative"...